Moderationpolicy - Историја измена

Tyfo у 12:40, 22. август 2017.

2017-08-22T12:40:08Z

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. август 2017. у 12:40
Ред 6:		Ред 6:
	In case there is any possible doubt, a player should be considered not guilty.		In case there is any possible doubt, a player should be considered not guilty.

	=== ~~Moderator Independence~~ ===		=== Conflict of Interest ===

	Moderators must not process reports if they know the involved parties (accuser or accused player). Playing online with the involved parties does not mean to "know" them. "Know" means: knowing them personally or playing with them online very regularly.		Moderators must not process reports if they know the involved parties (accuser or accused player). Playing online with the involved parties does not mean to "know" them. "Know" means: knowing them personally or playing with them online very regularly.

Tyfo у 12:32, 22. август 2017.

2017-08-22T12:32:03Z

Прикажи измене

Tyfo у 12:03, 22. август 2017.

2017-08-22T12:03:29Z

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. август 2017. у 12:03
Ред 6:		Ред 6:
	In case there is a any possible doubt, a player should be considered not guilty.		In case there is a any possible doubt, a player should be considered not guilty.

	=== Moderators independance ==		=== Moderators independance ===

	Moderators must not process reports if they know the protagonists (author or targeted player). Playing online with the protagonist does not mean to "know" them. "Know" means: know them personally or playing with them online very regularly.		Moderators must not process reports if they know the protagonists (author or targeted player). Playing online with the protagonist does not mean to "know" them. "Know" means: know them personally or playing with them online very regularly.

Tyfo у 12:03, 22. август 2017.

2017-08-22T12:03:22Z

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. август 2017. у 12:03
Ред 6:		Ред 6:
	In case there is a any possible doubt, a player should be considered not guilty.		In case there is a any possible doubt, a player should be considered not guilty.

	=== Moderators independance ===		=== Moderators independance ==

	Moderators must not process reports if they know the protagonists (author or targeted player). Playing online with the protagonist does not mean to "know" them. "Know" means: know them personally or playing with them online very regularly.		Moderators must not process reports if they know the protagonists (author or targeted player). Playing online with the protagonist does not mean to "know" them. "Know" means: know them personally or playing with them online very regularly.

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2016-11-22T08:06:45Z

Penalty grid

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. новембар 2016. у 08:06
Ред 117:		Ред 117:
	! Kingmaking		! Kingmaking
	\| Kingmaking action during a game		\| Kingmaking action during a game
	\| The report must contains ~~the~~ table id, the exact ~~move number~~, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it has to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty.		\| The report must contains SEVERAL table id of game with 3+ players (the CANNOT be any kingmaking on 2 players games), the exact moves numbers, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it has to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty. Note that 99% of kingmaking reports are not accurate enough, contains not enough information, and are closed because of this.
	\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.		\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that this is a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties.
	\|-		\|-

Sourisdudesert: /* Player profile influence */

2016-11-22T08:04:57Z

Player profile influence

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. новембар 2016. у 08:04
Ред 60:		Ред 60:
	* Players is involved in the website (ex: realized translations).		* Players is involved in the website (ex: realized translations).
	* Player is supporting BGA (member of the club).		* Player is supporting BGA (member of the club).

			You should also take into account the profile of the reporting player (report author) : a bad reputation and/or an important number of reports already judged as "not guilty" should incite you to be very careful with this player report.

	=== Incomplete reports ===		=== Incomplete reports ===

Sourisdudesert у 08:03, 22. новембар 2016.

2016-11-22T08:03:07Z

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. новембар 2016. у 08:03
Ред 131:		Ред 131:
	\| A player is using multiple accounts (most of the time: to boost his ELO rank)		\| A player is using multiple accounts (most of the time: to boost his ELO rank)
	\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. It is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP address, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.		\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. It is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP address, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.
			To detect multiple accounts, you should focus on ELO boosting, which is the reason of the multiple accounts 99% of the time. You should look at player game history, for a given game, and look at frequent opponents with a very good / perfect win rate.
	\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.		\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.
	\|-		\|-

Sourisdudesert: /* Prescription */

2016-11-22T07:59:43Z

Prescription

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 22. новембар 2016. у 07:59
Ред 45:		Ред 45:
	=== Prescription ===		=== Prescription ===

	For operational reason, a report that is older than 2 weeks may be closed by moderators because it is too old.		For operational reason, a report that is older than 12 weeks may be closed by moderators because it is too old.

			As a rule of thumb, every report should be judge in a 4 weeks delay.

	=== Player profile influence ===		=== Player profile influence ===

Sourisdudesert: /* About private jokes */

2014-01-06T13:24:42Z

About private jokes

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 6. јануар 2014. у 13:24
Ред 40:		Ред 40:

	If a wrong action happened in a private circle (ex: at a game table, with no spectators), and if none of the present players reported the action, the moderator must consider this was a "private joke" and must not apply any penalty. In the contrary, if the wrong action is public (ex: post/comment on the wall), the moderator may consider this as a wrong action even if there is no report.		If a wrong action happened in a private circle (ex: at a game table, with no spectators), and if none of the present players reported the action, the moderator must consider this was a "private joke" and must not apply any penalty. In the contrary, if the wrong action is public (ex: post/comment on the wall), the moderator may consider this as a wrong action even if there is no report.

			Note: in case a moderator discovers that this is obviously not a private joke and that something must be reported, the moderator is allowed to create a report for the case. However, in this case, this moderator is not allowed to judge the report.

	=== Prescription ===		=== Prescription ===

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty grid */

2014-01-06T12:23:54Z

Penalty grid

← Старија измена		Верзија на датум 6. јануар 2014. у 12:23
Ред 128:		Ред 128:
	\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. It is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP address, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.		\| The report must contains the usernames of all intimidated accounts, and the reason why the report author think that multiple accounts are used. It is very difficult to find out if different accounts corresponds to different person. For example: BGA accepts that multiple players plays from the same IP address, to allow people from the same family to play at the same table. In addition, some players are using multiple accounts, but these accounts are not playing together (which is acceptable). Strong tools are available for moderators to detect multiple accounts that are used the wrong way.
	\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.		\| For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.
			\|-
			! Something else
			\| Spam / advertising / inappropriate links
			\| The player is using BGA for advertising. In particular: links not related to the purpose of the page, advertising for other online boardgaming websites, spam, ...
			\|
	\|-		\|-
	! Something else		! Something else